Since the Sobolev energy is invariant under translations, any translation of a radial function achieves equality in the Pólya–Szegő inequality. There are however other functions that can achieve equality, obtained for example by taking a radial nonincreasing function that achieves its maximum on a ball of positive radius and adding to this function another function which is radial with respect to a different point and whose support is contained in the maximum set of the first function. In order to avoid this obstruction, an additional condition is thus needed. It has been proved that if the function achieves equality in the Pólya–Szegő inequality and if the set is a null set for Lebesgue's measure, then the function is radial and radially nonincreasing with respect to some point.
Generalizations
The Pólya–Szegő inequality is still valid for symmetrizations on the sphere or the hyperbolic space. The inequality also holds for partial symmetrizations defined by foliating the space into planes and into spheres. There are also Pólya−Szegő inequalities for rearrangements with respect to non-Euclidean norms and using the dual norm of the gradient.
Proofs of the inequality
Original proof by a cylindrical isoperimetric inequality
The original proof by Pólya and Szegő for was based on an isoperimetric inequality comparing sets with cylinders and an asymptotics expansion of the area of the area of the graph of a function. The inequality is proved for a smooth function that vanishes outside a compact subset of the Euclidean spaceFor every, they define the sets These sets are the sets of points who lie between the domain of the functions and and their respective graphs. They use then the geometrical fact that since the horizontal slices of both sets have the same measure and those of the second are balls, to deduce that the area of the boundary of the cylindrical set cannot exceed the one of. These areas can be computed by the area formula yielding the inequality Since the sets and have the same measure, this is equivalent to The conclusion then follows from the fact that
The Pólya–Szegő inequality can be proved by combining the coarea formula, Hölder’s inequality and the classical isoperimetric inequality. If the function is smooth enough, the coarea formula can be used to write where denotes the –dimensional Hausdorff measure on the Euclidean space. For almost every each, we have by Hölder's inequality, Therefore, we have Since the set is a ball that has the same measure as the set, by the classical isoperimetric inequality, we have Moreover, recalling that the sublevel sets of the functions and have the same measure, and therefore, Since the function is radial, one has and the conclusion follows by applying the coarea formula again.
Rearrangement inequalities for convolution
When, the Pólya–Szegő inequality can be proved by representing the Sobolev energy by the heat kernel. One begins by observing that where for, the function is the heat kernel, defined for every by Since for every the function is radial and radially decreasing, we have by the Riesz rearrangement inequality Hence, we deduce that