The first pastor in York was Rev John Smithies, who also established the Gerald Mission. While he was in York, tenders were called for construction of the "Wesleyan chapel" on 29 March 1853. Tenders were administered by John Henry Monger Snr,, publican and storekeeper, who lived in Faversham House next door to the north, a former engineer who must have been the building's designer. Monger's call for tenders stated: Local residents subscribed £200 to fund the construction and the government also assisted. Monger himself was the successful tenderer. Good progress on the chapel was reported in August 1853. Funding for roofing was being solicited in November 1853. George Wansbrough and his brother John worked on the roof. One local complained that ticket-of-leave men were not available to be employed in construction of the chapel. The chapel was opened on 5 April 1854 by the Rev. William Lowe to a crowd of more than 120 people. The cost of the chapel was £317/12/4. This chapel was the second church in York. Originally there was a gallery in the chapel but this was later removed. A harmonium was purchased for the chapel in 1859. Attendees paid pew rents, 5 shillings for a whole seat and 1 shilling for an individual. The cost of upkeep of the chapel was recorded in 1868 as being £15/19/-, of which candles for illumination constituted a large proportion. The chapel keeper was paid 1 shilling per week for his services. Monger's design is harmonic, simple and symmetrical, being Victorian Georgian style.
Church
After Reverend Thomas Bird arrived in August 1878, he saw that the chapel was too small and started plans for a new church and to use the old one for the Sunday School, and social and business meetings. In 1885, the trustees and the Rev William Lowe held a meeting to discuss plans for building the church. The “Wesleyan body generally responded to the demand upon their resources” and by March 1888 most of the money had reportedly been raised. Tenders were called and the successful tender was from Pringle and Moscrip of Perth and Adelaide for £945. The foundation stone was laid by Mrs J H Monger on 25 April 1888. The foundation stone “is a most beautiful specimen of Sydney free stone, and will be carved during the coming week by Mr Pringle, one of the contractors, by whom it is presented”. "Every preparation was made by the obliging contractor for the ceremony on Wednesday. The scaffolding was adorned with bunting hours before the company assembled. Stones were removed and planks placed for the comfort of those taking part in the service.” A “hermetically sealed” bottle containing a list of parishioners and some silver and copper coins common in the colony, was placed under the foundation stone by Joseph Pyke, and Mr Pringle presented Mrs Monger with a silver trowel. On the evening of the laying of the foundation stone, there was a promenade concert in the Oddfellows’ Hall. “The best musical talent that the district affords has been secured” and “with one or two exceptions” this concert was declared a success and raised £17 for the building fund. The cost of the Church was reputed to be £1,000 and in May 1888 there were concerns that only £400 had been raised. In fact, only £236 had been raised, all of the donors to that time being listed in an advertisement the following month, the largest of them being John Henry Monger who was paying in instalments. Donations continued to be published and the total crept to £345. Stone for the church was donated and carted to the site by adherents. By June, it was reported that construction of the Church was fast reaching completion and would be finished by the first Sunday in August 1888.
Opening of the Church
The last two services for the Chapel were held by the Rev Thomas Bird and the Rev William Lowe on 19 August. The Rev Thomas Bird held the opening service in the new Church on Wednesday 22 August 1888 at 3:45 pm. The local newspaper, the Eastern Districts Chronicle reported:
Architecture
The architect of the church was Alfred McBain Bonython who had come from Adelaide and Melbourne and was living in Perth designing buildings for the Shenton family. He was only 23 at the time. He also designed the Wesleyan Methodist churches in Fremantle and Albany. The church is in Victorian Academic Gothic style. Gothic features include:
A fund was raised by Mrs Florence Monger in 1895 for the purchase of an organ constructed by Alfred Monk of London. The organ is only one of two Alfred Monk organs in Australia and is considered the best 19th century organ in Western Australia "in both the warmth of its tone and brilliance of sound and in capability to fill the sanctuary with sound". Originally, the organ had to be hand-pumped. An organ pumper recollected: The names of a number of the organ pumpers are scratched in the back of the organ case. In 1925, an electric blower was installed. The organ was restored in 1981-2 by FJ Larner & Co and was cleaned and maintained in June 2001. The gallery in the church was originally intended to be used by the choir but the installation of the pipe organ meant that the choir assembled at the front of the church.
Bell
The bell of the church was cast at the London foundry of John Warner & Sons in 1905. The bell is 510mm in diameter and weighs approximately 91kg. The bell was donated by Mr Thomas Harkness with the condition that it be run a half hour before the morning and evening services for a short time and then for a full five minutes before each service commenced, presumably to give Harkness time to get to church by horse and buggy. Originally the bell was mounted on a wooden tower at the back of the chapel. When that became unsafe it was replace by a metal tower. In November 2010, the bell was erected in the present tower which was paid for by public subscription.
