Waardenburg syndrome
Waardenburg syndrome is a group of rare genetic conditions characterised by at least some degree of congenital hearing loss and pigmentation deficiencies, which can include bright blue eyes, a white forelock or patches of light skin. These basic features constitute type 2 of the condition; in type 1, there is also a wider gap between the inner corners of the eyes called telecanthus, or dystopia canthorum. In type 3, which is rare, the arms and hands are also malformed, with permanent finger contractures or fused fingers, while in type 4 the person also has Hirschsprung's disease, which is a congenital lack of nerves in the intestines leading to bowel dysfunction. There also exist at least two types that can result in central nervous system symptoms such as developmental delay and muscle tone abnormalities.
The syndrome is caused by mutations in any of several genes that affect the division and migration of neural crest cells during embryonic development. Neural crest cells are stem cells left over after the closing of the neural tube that go on to form diverse non-central nervous system cells in different parts of the body, including melanocytes, various bones and cartilage of the face and inner ear and the peripheral nerves of the intestines. Type 1 is caused by a mutation in the PAX3 gene, while the gene that most often causes type 2 when mutated is MITF. Type 3 is a more severe presentation of type 1 and is caused by a mutation in the same gene, while type 4 is most often caused by a mutation in SOX10. Other genes can also cause the different types, and some of these have been given their own lettered subtypes. Most types are autosomal dominant.
The estimated prevalence of Waardenburg syndrome is 1 in 42,000. Types 1 and 2 are the most common, comprising approximately half and a third of cases respectively, while type 4 comprises a fifth and type 3 less than 2% of cases. An estimated 2–5% of congenitally deaf people have Waardenburg syndrome. Descriptions of the syndrome date back to at least the first half of the 20th century, however it is named after Dutch ophthalmologist and geneticist Petrus Johannes Waardenburg, who described it in 1951. Its subtypes were progressively discovered in the following decades and had genes attributed to them mostly in the 1990s and 2000s.
Signs and symptoms
Waardenburg syndrome has multiple different types with some variations in symptoms, and symptoms can vary among those with the same type. The two features consistent across all types of Waardenburg syndrome are some degree of congenital sensorineural hearing loss and some degree of pigmentation deficiencies, most consistently in the eyes.Type 1
Type 1 is characterised by congenital sensorineural hearing loss, pigmentary deficiencies of the hair such as a white lock of hair in the front-centre of the head or premature greying, pigmentary deficiencies of the eyes such as different coloured eyes, multiple colours in an eye or brilliant blue eyes, patches of skin depigmentation and a wider gap between the inner corners of the eyes called telecanthus, or dystopia canthorum. Other facial features associated with type 1 can include a high nasal bridge, a flat nose tip, a unibrow, smaller edges of the nostrils or a smooth philtrum.Type 2
The difference that defines type 2 from type 1 is that patients do not have the wider gap between the inner corners of the eyes. Sensorineural hearing loss tends to be more common and more severe in this type. By far the most common gene to cause this type when mutated is MITF. If two individuals with a mutation in this gene have a child carrying both mutations, for which there is 25% chance, additional symptoms are present in the child, such as a hole in the iris, small eyes, hardened bones, macrocephaly, albinism and deafness.There are two known patients identified with mutations in both copies of SNAI2 ; these individuals presented with Waardenburg syndrome type 2 but did not have hair pigmentation deficiencies.
When Waardenburg syndrome type 2 is caused by a mutation in SOX10, it can on some occasions present with multiple neurological symptoms. These can include developmental delay, early childhood nystagmus, increased muscle tone, white matter anomalies or hypomyelination in the brain, autistic-like behaviour and the underdevelopment or complete absence of many inner-ear structures such as the vestibular system or cochlea. Lack of a sense of smell due to a missing olfactory bulb in the brain may also be present.
Type 3
Also known as Klein–Waardenburg syndrome, or Waardenburg–Klein syndrome, type 3 has the same symptoms as type 1 but has additional symptoms that affect the arms and hands. These can include joint contractures of the fingers, due to underdeveloped muscles, as well as fused digits or winged scapulae. Microcephaly and developmental delay are also possible.Type 4
Also known as Shah–Waardenburg syndrome, or Waardenburg–Shah syndrome, type 4 has most of the same features as type 2 but with the addition of Hirschsprung's disease, which is a congenital lack of nerves in the intestines leading to bowel dysfunction. Additionally, hearing loss isn't as common as in type 2. Rarely, cleft lip has been reported in this form of Waardenburg syndrome.Type 4 can also be caused by a mutation in SOX10, in which it is known as type 4C; hearing loss is very common and severe in this type.
PCWH
A mutation in SOX10, the gene involved in type 2E and type 4C, can sometimes result in the symptoms of both types. When this happens, it is called peripheral demyelinating neuropathy–central dysmyelinating leukodystrophy–Waardenburg syndrome–Hirschsprung disease.Cause
Waardenburg syndrome is caused by mutations in any of several genes that affect the operation of neural crest cells in embryonic development. Most types of Waardenburg syndrome are caused by autosomal dominant mutations. The few that are autosomal recessive are rare. In most cases, an affected person has inherited it from one parent with one of the dominant forms of the condition. A small percentage of cases result from spontaneous new mutations in the gene, where there is no family history of the condition.The neural crest is a group of temporary migratory cells that are left over after the neural tube has closed, around the fourth week of embryonic development. They are responsible for differentiating into a diverse group of cells that reach different areas of the body. The neural tube and neural crest are derived from the ectoderm; the neural tube goes on to form the brain and spinal cord, while the neural crest cells eventually go on to form various bones and cartilage of the skull and face by migrating through the pharyngeal arches. They also differentiate into the stria vascularis of the cochlea, the nerves and glia of the intestines, Schwann cells, which myelinate the peripheral nervous system to allow sufficient conductivity, odontoblasts, which produce dentin deep in the teeth, some neuroendocrine cells, connective tissue around the salivary, lacrimal, pituitary, thymus and thyroid glands, connective tissue of the eye, such as the stroma of the iris and cornea and the trabecular meshwork, and melanocytes, including those in the stroma of the iris that give rise to brown eye colour through melanin. Neural crest cells also have a role in muscle formation, including the wall muscle of certain cardiac arteries.
Causes of subtypes
- Type 1 is caused by an autosomal dominant mutation in the gene PAX3. PAX3, or paired box 3, is a transcription factor that has a role in maintaining an open window of time for certain neural crest cells to divide and migrate before their terminal differentiation. Mutations in this gene therefore prematurely arrest their division and migration, resulting in a minor lack of development of certain face cartilage and bones, as well as underdeveloped inner ear structures and a lack of melanocytes in the iris stroma. There is evidence that PAX3 also regulates cells from before the neural crest forms, i.e. the neural tube, since mice with loss-of-function mutations in one of the copies of PAX3 have neural tube defects such as spina bifida or exencephaly.
- Type 2 is caused by a mutation in any of a range of genes, the most common being MITF, when it is classed as type 2A.
- * Type 2A is caused by an autosomal dominant mutation in the gene MITF. MITF, or microphthalmia-associated transcription factor, is a transcription factor that has a more specialised role in the neural crest and is more strictly involved after the neural crest forms. It is known to allow melanocytes, osteoclasts, mast cells and retinal pigment epithelial cells to divide and migrate. The involvement in osteoclasts explains why mutations in both copies of MITF can lead to bone hardening, as the osteoclasts are responsible for breaking down bone. MITF also activates transcription of tyrosinase, the enzyme that performs the first step in the creation of melanin. A mutation in a copy of MITF can also lead to Tietz syndrome, which is distinguished from Waardenburg syndrome by uniform albinism instead of patchy depigmentation.
- * Type 2B is caused by an autosomal dominant mutation in an unknown gene on chromosome 1 in the locus range of 1p21–1p13.3. The gene has been provisionally termed WS2B.
- * Type 2C is caused by an autosomal dominant mutation in an unknown gene on chromosome 8 in the locus of 8p23. The gene has been provisionally termed WS2C.
- * Type 2D is caused by an autosomal recessive mutation in both copies of the gene SNAI2. In the study that discovered this association, it was found that SNAI2 is activated by MITF as part of neural crest development, and that this explained why mutations in MITF cause Waardenburg syndrome, as it results in a lack of activation of SNAI2. Mutations in a single copy of SNAI2 have also been found to cause patches of hair depigmentation without any other symptoms.
- * Type 2E is caused by an autosomal dominant mutation in the gene SOX10.
- *Rarely, a mutation in a gene other than those currently known may be responsible for a Waardenburg syndrome with features of type 2. This is usually initially classified as simply type 2 but may be given its own subtype once a gene or locus is identified and established.
- Type 3 is caused by a mutation in the gene PAX3, the same gene as in type 1. It can be inherited in an autosomal dominant or autosomal recessive manner; it is possible for two parents with Waardenburg syndrome type 1 to have a child carrying both mutated copies of the PAX3 gene and present with Waardenburg syndrome type 3. A missense mutation has been documented to have this effect. However, it is also possible for Waardenburg syndrome type 3 to present spontaneously with just one mutated copy of PAX3. A deletion of the paired domain region of the gene has been documented to have this effect. However, no major correlation has been found between type of mutation and disease severity. Severity tends to be dictated by mutations in other genes, as evidenced by distinct familial patterns in severity not tied to Waardenburg mutation type. Mutations in both copies of PAX3 have sometimes led to death before or shortly after birth, and mice with loss-of-function mutations in both copies of the gene do not survive.
- Type 4 is caused by a mutation in any of a range of genes, the most common being SOX10, when it is classed as type 4C.
- * Type 4A is caused by an autosomal dominant or autosomal recessive mutation in the gene EDNRB.
- * Type 4B is caused by an autosomal dominant or autosomal recessive mutation in the gene EDN3.
- * Type 4C is caused by an autosomal dominant or autosomal recessive mutation in the gene SOX10, the same gene as in type 2E.
Classification table
Treatment
There is currently no treatment or cure for Waardenburg syndrome. The symptom most likely to be of practical importance is deafness, and this is treated as any other irreversible deafness would be. In marked cases, there may be cosmetic issues. Other abnormalities associated with the syndrome are treated symptomatically.Epidemiology
The prevalence of all types of Waardenburg syndrome is estimated at around 1 in 42,000. Types 1 and 2 are by far the most common, with type 1 appearing to be slightly more common. In a 2015 review looking at 417 patients, type 1 was found to be the most common type, encompassing around half of all cases, while type 2 was the second-most common type, encompassing around a third. The vast majority of type 2 cases are type 2A. The prevalence of type 2B is unknown, as it was only reported in one 1996 study. Type 2C has so far only been found in one Italian family, and type 2D had only been found in 2 unrelated patients as of 2018. The number of known cases of type 2E that involved neurological abnormalities was reported to be 23 as of 2017, while the number of the rest is unknown. Type 3 is rarer than types 1, 2 and 4, comprising less than 2% of cases. Type 4 appears to encompass around a fifth of cases. Of its subtypes, type 4C is by far the most common, followed by type 4A and type 4B.It is estimated that Waardenburg syndrome is present in 2–5% of congenitally deaf people. Congenital deafness comprises around half of deafness as a whole. About 1 in 30 students in schools for the deaf have Waardenburg syndrome. The variable presentation of the syndrome makes it difficult to arrive at precise figures for its prevalence.
History
Early descriptions
In 1916, Dutch ophthalmologist Jan van der Hoeve described a pair of twin girls with deafness and a particular type of blepharophimosis, believed to be the dystopia canthorum found in Waardenburg syndrome types 1 and 3. Blepharophimosis describes eyelids which are underdeveloped such that they permanently cover part of the eyes.In 1926, German physician Irmgard Mende described a family of four generations in which five children had symptoms of depigmentation of hair, skin and eyes, deafness and a "mongoloid" appearance. This later led to the synonym Mende syndrome being recorded in some databases.
In 1929, Dutch physician K. T. A. Halbertsma described a familial pattern to dystopia canthorum, and in 1930 Italian physician Vincenzo Gualdi also confirmed a hereditary pattern to dystopia canthorum. This later led to the synonym Van der Hoeve–Halbertsma–Waardenburg–Gualdi syndrome being recorded in some databases.
In 1947, Swiss ophthamologist David Klein first reported a patient with bilateral deafness, pigmentation deficiencies, characteristic facial features and malformation of the arms. Although this was the first full description of a patient with Waardenburg syndrome type 3, contemporary clinicians did not consider the syndrome he described to be the same as that described by Waardenburg four years later, in part due to how severe the arm malformations were in his patient.
The syndrome was first fully formalised and described by Dutch ophthalmologist and geneticist Petrus Johannes Waardenburg in 1951. The condition he described is now categorised as Waardenburg syndrome type 1.
Descriptions of subtypes
Type 2 was first established in 1971 when a study noticed that some Waardenburg syndrome patients did not have dystopia canthorum. A 1977 study confirmed a familial pattern to this other presentation. Two 1994 studies first confirmed a link between this type of Waardenburg syndrome and mutations in the MITF gene, located on chromosome 3 at locus 3p14.1–p12.3.Type 2B was first established in 1994 when the same study which found mutations in MITF in patients with Waardenburg syndrome type 2 also found that some patients did not have any mutations in this region. A second 1994 study found a link to chromosome 1 in the locus 1p21–p13.3. This became known as type 2B of the condition, however it has not been documented since, and the gene responsible remains unknown.
Type 2C was established in 2001 when a study of an Italian family with Waardenburg syndrome type 2 features found that they were due to an unknown gene on chromosome 8 at locus 8q23 which had been broken by a chromosomal translocation. The study established a provisional name for the gene, WS2C. However, mutations in this region in Waardenburg syndrome patients have not been found since.
Type 2D was established in 2002 when a study looking to find mutations in the human version of the SNAI2 gene, known to cause depigmentation in mice, found deletions of both copies of this gene in 2 unrelated individuals with Waardenburg syndrome type 2. Mutations in both copies of this gene have not been found in those with Waardenburg syndrome type 2 since.
Type 2E was first established in 1996 when a study identified a girl with symptoms of Waardenburg syndrome type 2 but with additional underdevelopment of the front of the eye, leading to blindness. In 1999, it was found that she had a mutation in her SOX10 gene, and later studies confirmed the association between mutations in this gene and this phenotype, as well as neurological symptoms such as developmental delay.
Type 3 was first given its name by Goodman et al. in 1981, in collaboration with Klein, in which they established the association with arm abnormalities first reported by Klein in 1947. Mutations in PAX3 were first linked to this phenotype in 1992.
The comorbidity with Hirschsprung's disease, which would later constitute type 4, was first noticed in various studies in the 1970s. Indian paediatrician Krishnakumar Shah and his associates first outlined the syndrome as a possible variant of Waardenburg syndrome in 1981. The variant was first attributed to a mutation in EDNRB in 1994. Type 4B was established in 1996 when mutations in EDN3 were found to lead to this type of Waardenburg syndrome, and type 4C was first established in 1998 when mutations in SOX10 were also found to lead to this type.
Society and culture
Popular culture
- The 2001 novel Shock by Robin Cook mentions a character with the disorder.
- Enzo MacLeod, protagonist of Peter May's 2006–2017 book series The Enzo Files, has Waardenburg syndrome. His eyes are different colors, and he has a white streak in his hair.
- In the 2011 season 6 episode of Bones "The Signs in the Silence", the team must solve a case in which the suspected killer has Waardenburg syndrome.
- The 2013 book Reconstructing Amelia by Kimberly McCreight features several characters with Waardenburg symptoms.
- The 2014 book Closer Than You Think by Karen Rose features three characters, siblings, with Waardenburg syndrome.
- The 2017 book Murder at the Mayan Temple by M.J. Mandrake features several characters with Waardenburg syndrome.
- The 2019 novel The Whisper Network by Chandler Baker uses the syndrome as a plot point.
Notable people
- Popular Canadian YouTube vlogger Stef Sanjati has Waardenburg syndrome type 1.
Other animals
Domesticated cats with blue eyes and white coats are often completely deaf. Deafness is far more common in white cats than in those with other coat colors. According to the ASPCA Complete Guide to Cats, "17 to 20 percent of white cats with non-blue eyes are deaf; 40 percent of "odd-eyed" white cats with one blue eye are deaf; and 65 to 85 percent of blue-eyed white cats are deaf." Although few studies have been done to link this to genes known to be involved in human Waardenburg syndrome, a genetic disruption to neural crest development would lead to this presentation in cats as well. One of the genes that leads to deafness and a white coat in cats when mutated, KIT, has been found to increase MITF expression.
Lethal white syndrome is a syndrome in horses caused by mutations in both copies of EDNRB. It leads to death from intestinal pseudo-obstruction due to Hirschsprung's disease. A mutation in a single copy of EDNRB, however, as in Waardenburg syndrome type 4A, produces the patchy white overo coat with deafness.
Ferrets with Waardenburg syndrome have a small white stripe along the top or back of the head and sometimes down the back of the neck, or a solid white head from nose to shoulders. Affected ferrets often have a very slightly flatter skull and wider-set eyes than healthy ferrets. As healthy ferrets have poor hearing, deafness may only be detected by lack of reaction to loud noises. As this is an inherited disorder, affected animals should not be used for breeding. A study of the correlation between coat variations and deafness in European ferrets found "All panda, American panda, and blaze ferrets were deaf."