The Wanzlick equilibrium is a chemical equilibrium between a relatively stable carbenecompound and its dimer. The equilibrium was proposed to apply to certain electron-rich alkenes, such as tetraminoethylenes, which have been called "carbene dimers." Such equilibria occur, but the mechanism does not proceed simply, but requires catalysts.
Original conjecture
In 1960, H.-W. Wanzlick and E. Schikora proposed that carbenes derived from dihydroimidazol-2-ylidene were generated by vacuum pyrolysis of 2-trichloromethyl dihydroimidazole derivatives, with the loss of chloroform. Wanzlick and Schikora believed that once prepared these carbenes existed in an unfavourable equilibrium with their corresponding dimers. This assertion was based on reactivity studies which they believed showed that the free carbene reacted with electrophiles. The dimer was believed to be inactive to the electrophiles, and thought to merelyact as a stable carbene reservoir.
Conjecture challenged
Wanzlick’s hypothesis of a carbene-dimer equilibrium was tested by D. Lemal and others. Heating mixtures of tetraaminoethylene derivatives did not producemixed dimers: This result indicates that a 'carbene-dimer equilibrium' does not occur for these dihydroimidazol-2-ylidene derivatives. Lemal proposed that Wanzlick's observations could be explained by acid-catalyzed reactions. with electrophiles. In conditions of excess E-X, the salt is formed. In conditions of catalytic E-X, the dimer will be formed. However, this is based on the assumption that the dimer is more stable than the carbene; but this assumption has been questioned. E-X may be an acid or even a metal salt e.g. LiCl. Lemal proposed that the electrophile converts the tetraaminoethylenes into cationicspecies. He proposed that this cation then dissociated into the free carbene plus the resultant salt. The free carbene could then either re-dimerise, regenerating the tetraaminoethylene starting material, or react with E-X, with either route eventually giving the same reaction product, the dihydroimidazolium salt.
Conjecture confirmed
In 1999 M. Denk reinvestigated the cross-over experiments that supported the Wanzlick equilibrium. This report prompted Lemal to repeat his 1964 experiments. Denk's findings were confirmed only with deuterated tetrahydrofuran as a solvent. With toluene and added KH as an electrophile quencher, however, the cross-over product was again not observed. In 1999 Lemal and others investigated an equilibrium between a dibenzotetraazafulvalene derivative and its carbene. These studies led Böhm & Herrmann to conclude in 2000 that "the Wanzlick equilibrium between a tetraaminoethylene and its corresponding carbene did exist". This notion was confirmed in 2010 by Kirmse. Others subsequently showed that unhindered diaminocarbenes form dimers by acid-catalysed dimerisation as shown in the Lemal.
