Proto-Greek language
The Proto-Greek language is an Indo-European language. It is assumed to be the last common ancestor of all known varieties of Greek, including Mycenaean Greek, the subsequent ancient Greek dialects and, ultimately, Koine, Byzantine and Modern Greek together with its variants. The unity of Proto-Greek would have ended as Hellenic migrants, who spoke the predecessor of Mycenaean Greek, entered the Greek peninsula sometime in the Bronze Age.
Origins
Proto-Greek was originally a dialect of the Proto-Indo-European language. In the late Neolithic, speakers of this dialect, which would become Proto-Greek, migrated from their homeland to the Balkans and into the Greek peninsula. The evolution of Proto-Greek could be considered within the context of an early Paleo-Balkan sprachbund that makes it difficult to delineate exact boundaries between individual languages. The characteristically Greek representation of word-initial laryngeals by prothetic vowels is shared, for one, by the Armenian language, which also seems to share some other phonological and morphological peculiarities of Greek; this has led some linguists to propose a hypothetically closer relationship between Greek and Armenian, although evidence remains scant.Proto-Greek is mostly placed in the Early Helladic period towards the end of the Neolithic in Southern Europe. Ivo Hajnal dates the beginning of the differentiation of Proto-Greek into the Greek dialects to a point not significantly earlier than 1700 BC, however.
Phonology
Proto-Greek is reconstructed with the following phonemes:;Consonants
;Vowels
Type | Front | Center | Back |
Close | i ī | u ū | |
Mid | e ē | ə | o ō |
Open | a ā |
- Diphthongs are ai ei oi ui, au eu ou, āi ēi ōi, and possibly āu ēu ōu; all are allophonic with the corresponding sequences of vowel and semivowel.
- Exactly one vowel in each word bears a pitch accent.
Proto-Greek changes
- Devoicing of voiced aspirates.
- Merger of palatovelars and velars.
- Merging of sequences of velar + *w into the labiovelars, with compensatory lengthening of the consonant in some cases. For example, PIE *h₁éḱwos > PG *híkkʷos > Mycenaean i-qo, Attic híppos, Aeolic íkkos.
- Shortening of long vowels before a sonorant in the same syllable : "skyling, sky god" > Attic Greek Zeús.
- Debuccalization of to in intervocalic and prevocalic positions.
- Palatalization of consonants followed by -y-, producing various affricate consonants and geminated palatal consonants; they later simplified, mostly losing their palatal character.
- Dissimilation of aspirates, possibly post-Mycenaean.
- Vocalization of laryngeals between consonants and initially before consonants to,, from *h₁, *h₂, *h₃ respectively.
- Other unique changes involving laryngeals; see below.
- Strengthening of word-initial y- to dy- > dz-.
- Loss of final stop consonants.
- Final >.
- Raising of to between a resonant and a labial.
Dissimilation of aspirates caused an initial aspirated sound to lose its aspiration when a following aspirated consonant occurred in the same word. It was a relatively late change in Proto-Greek history and must have occurred independently of the similar dissimilation of aspirates in Indo-Iranian, although it may represent a common areal feature:
- It postdates the Greek-specific de-voicing of voiced aspirates.
- It also postdates the change of >, as it affects as well: ékhō "I have" < *hekh- < PIE *seǵʰ-oh₂, but future heksō "I will have" < *heks- < Post-PIE *seǵʰ-s-oh₂.
- It postdates even the loss of aspiration before that accompanied second-stage palatalization, which postdates both of the previous changes.
- On the other hand, it predates the development of the first aorist passive marker -thē- since the aspirate in that marker has no effect on preceding aspirates.
Laryngeal changes
Greek shows distinct reflexes of the laryngeals in various positions:
- Most famously, between consonants, where original vocalic *h₁, *h₂, *h₃ are reflected as,, respectively. All other Indo-European languages reflect the same vowel from all three laryngeals :
Proto-Indo-European | Greek | Vedic Sanskrit | Latin |
*dʰh̥₁s- "sacred, religious" | θέσφατος "decreed by God" | धिष्ण्य "devout" | fānum "temple" < *fasnom < *dʰh̥₁s-no- |
*sth̥₂-to- "standing, being made to stand" | στατός | स्थित | status |
*dh̥₃-ti- "gift" | δόσις | दिति | datiō |
- An initial laryngeal before a consonant leads to the same triple reflex, but most IE languages lost such laryngeals and a few reflect them initially before consonants. Greek vocalized them : Greek érebos "darkness" < PIE *h₁regʷos vs. Gothic riqiz- "darkness"; Greek áent- "wind" < *awent- < PIE *h₂wéh₁n̥t- vs. English wind, Latin ventum "wind", Breton gwent "wind".
- The sequence *CRHC becomes CRēC, CRāC, CRōC from H = *h₁, *h₂, *h₃ respectively. Sometimes, CeReC, CaRaC, CoRoC are found instead: Greek thánatos "death" vs. Doric Greek thnātós "mortal", both apparently reflecting *dʰn̥h₂-tos. It is sometimes suggested that the position of the accent was a factor in determining the outcome.
- The sequence *CiHC tends to become *CyēC, *CyāC, *CyōC from H = *h₁, *h₂, *h₃ respectively, with later palatalization. Sometimes, the outcome CīC is found, as in most other Indo-European languages, or the outcome CiaC in the case of *Cih₂C.
- *CHC > *CHeC > CeC/CaC/CoC.
- *HC- > *HeC- > eC-/aC-/oC-.
- *CRHC > *CReHC > CRēC/CRāC/CRōC; or, *CRHC > *CeRHeC > *CeReC/CeRaC/CeRoC > CeReC/CaRaC/CoRoC by assimilation.
- *CiHC > *CyeHC > CyēC/CyāC/CyōC; or, *Cih₂C > *Cih₂eC > *CiHaC > *CiyaC > CiaC; or, *CiHC remains without vowel insertion > CīC.
- The sequence *CRHV passes through *CR̥HV, becoming CaRV.
- The sequence *CeHC becomes CēC/CāC/CōC.
- The sequence *CoHC becomes CōC.
- In the sequence *CHV, the laryngeal colors a following short, as expected, but it otherwise disappears entirely.
- In a *VHV sequence, the laryngeal again colours any adjacent short but otherwise vanishes early on. That change appears to be uniform across the Indo-European languages and was probably the first environment in which laryngeals were lost. If the first V was *i, *u or a vocalic resonant, a consonantal copy was apparently inserted in place of the laryngeal: *CiHV > *CiyV, *CuHV > *CuwV, *CR̥HV possibly > *CR̥RV, with R̥ always remaining as vocalic until the dissolution of vocalic resonants in the various daughter languages. Otherwise, a hiatus resulted, which was resolved in various ways in the daughter languages, typically by converting i, u and vocalic resonants, when it directly followed a vowel, back into a consonant and merging adjacent non-high vowels into a single long vowel.
Palatalization
The first palatalization turned dentals + *y into alveolar affricates:
Before | After |
*ty, *tʰy | *ts |
*dy | *dz |
Alongside these changes, the inherited clusters *ts, *ds and *tʰs all merged into *ts.
In the second palatalization, all consonants were affected. It took place following the resolution of syllabic laryngeals and sonorants. The following table, based on American linguist Andrew Sihler, shows the developments.
Before | After |
*py, *pʰy | *pť |
*tsy | *ťť |
*ky, *kʰy | *ťť |
*kʷy, *kʷʰy | *ťť |
*by | ? |
*dzy | *ďď |
*gy | *ďď |
*gʷy | *ďď |
*ly | *ľľ |
*my, *ny | *ňň |
*ry | *řř |
*sy > *hy | *yy |
*wy | *ɥɥ > *yy |
In post-Proto-Greek times, the resulting palatal consonants and clusters were resolved in varying ways. Most notably, *ň and *ř were resolved into plain sonorants plus a palatal on-glide, which eventually turned the preceding vowel into a diphthong.
In the time between the first and second palatalizations, new clusters *tsy and *dzy were formed by restoring a lost *y after the newly formed *ts and *dz. This occurred only in morphologically transparent formations, by analogy with similar formations where *y was preceded by other consonants. In formations that were morphologically opaque and not understood as such by speakers of the time, this restoration did not take place and *ts and *dz remained. Hence, depending on the type of formation, the Pre-Greek sequences *ty, *tʰy and *dy have different outcomes in the later languages. In particular, medial *ty becomes Attic s in opaque formations, but tt in transparent formations.
The outcome of PG medial *ts in Homeric Greek is s after a long vowel, and vacillation between s and ss after a short vowel: tátēsi dat. pl. "rug" < tátēt-, possí/posí dat. pl. "foot" < pod-. This was useful for the composer of the Iliad and Odyssey, since possí with double s scans as long-short, while posí with single s scans as short-short. Thus the writer could use each form in different positions in a line.
Examples of initial *ts:
- PIE *tyegʷ- "avoid" > PG *tsegʷ- > Greek sébomai "worship, be respectful"
- PIE *dʰyeh₂- "notice" > PG *tsā- > Dor. sā́ma, Att. sêma "sign"
- PreG *tótyos "as much" > PG *tótsos > Att. tósos, Hom. tósos/tóssos
- PIE *médʰyos "middle" > PG *métsos > Att. mésos, Hom. mésos/méssos, Boeot. méttos, other dial. mésos
- PIE *h₁erh₁-t-yoh₂ "I row" > PG *eréťťō > Attic eréttō, usual non-Attic eréssō
- PIE *krét-yōs > PreG *krétyōn "better" > PG *kréťťōn > Attic kreíttōn, usual non-Attic kréssōn
Other Post-Proto-Greek changes
- Remaining syllabic resonants and are resolved to vowels or combinations of a vowel and consonantal resonant. It appears that the process still occurred within Proto-Greek, and resulted in an epenthetic vowel of undetermined quality. This vowel then usually developed into a but also o in some cases. Thus:
- *, > *ə, but > *əm, *ən before a sonorant. *ə appears as o in Mycenaean after a labial: pe-mo "seed" vs. usual spérma < *spérmn̥. Similarly, o often appears in Arcadian after a velar, e.g. déko "ten", hekotón "one hundred" vs. usual déka, hekatón < *déḱm̥, *sem-ḱm̥tóm.
- *, > *lə, *rə, but *əl, *ər before sonorants and analogously. *ə appears as o in Mycenaean Greek, Aeolic Greek and Cypro-Arcadian. Example: PIE *str̥-tos > usual stratós, Aeolic strótos "army"; post-PIE *ḱr̥di-eh₂ "heart" > Attic kardíā, Homeric kradíē, Pamphylian korzdia.
- Loss of s in consonant clusters, with compensatory lengthening of the preceding vowel or of the consonant : *ésmi "I am" > ḗmi, eîmi or émmi.
- Creation of secondary s from clusters, *nty > ns.
- Conversion of labiovelars to velars next to, the "boukólos rule".
- In southern dialects, -ti- > -si-.
- Loss of , except initially, e.g. Doric níkaas "having conquered" < *níkahas < *níkasas.
- Loss of, e.g. treîs "three" < *tréyes.
- Loss of in many dialects. Example: étos "year" from *wétos.
- Loss of labiovelars, which were converted into labials, sometimes into dentals. See below for details. It had not yet happened in Mycenaean, as is shown by the fact that a separate letter is used for such sounds.
- Contraction of adjacent vowels resulting from loss of and ; more in Attic Greek than elsewhere.
- Rise of a distinctive circumflex accent, resulting from contraction and certain other changes.
- Limitation of the accent to the last three syllables, with various further restrictions.
- Loss of before , with compensatory lengthening of the preceding vowel.
- Raising of ā to ē in Attic and Ionic dialects. In Ionic, the change was general, but in Attic it did not occur after /i/, /e/ or /r/.
Loss of and after a consonant was often accompanied by compensatory lengthening of a preceding vowel.
The development of labiovelars varies from dialect to dialect:
- Due to the PIE boukólos rule, labiovelars next to had already been converted to plain velars: boukólos "herdsman" < *gʷou-kʷólos vs. aipólos "goatherd" < *ai-kʷólos ; elakhús "small" < *h₁ln̥gʷʰ-ús vs. elaphrós "light" < *h₁ln̥gʷʰ-rós.
- In Attic and some other dialects, labiovelars before some front vowels became dentals. In Attic, kʷ and kʷʰ became t and th, respectively, before and, while gʷ became d before . Cf. theínō "I strike, kill" < *gʷʰen-yō vs. phónos "slaughter" < *gʷʰón-os; delphús "womb" < *gʷelbʰ- vs. bíos "life" < *gʷih₃wos, tís "who?" < *kʷis.
- All remaining labiovelars became labials, original kʷ kʷʰ gʷ becoming p ph b respectively. That happened to all labiovelars in some dialects like Lesbian; in other dialects, like Attic, it occurred to all labiovelars not converted into dentals. Many occurrences of dentals were later converted into labials by analogy with other forms: bélos "missile", bélemnon "spear, dart" by analogy with bállō "I throw ", bolḗ "a blow with a missile".
- Original PIE labiovelars had still remained as such even before consonants and so became labials also there. In many other centum languages such as Latin and most Germanic languages, the labiovelars lost their labialisation before consonants. This makes Greek of particular importance in reconstructing original labiovelars.
Morphology
Noun
As Mycenaean Greek shows, the PIE dative, instrumental and locative cases are still distinct and are not yet syncretized into other cases.Nominative plural -oi, -ai replaces late PIE -ōs, -ās.
The superlative in -tatos becomes productive.
The peculiar oblique stem gunaik- "women", attested from the Thebes tablets is probably Proto-Greek. It appears, at least as gunai- in Armenian as well.
Pronoun
The pronouns hoûtos, ekeînos and autós are created. The use of ho, hā, to as articles is post-Mycenaean.Verb
Proto-Greek inherited the augment, a prefix e-, to verbal forms expressing past tense. That feature is shared only with Indo-Iranian and Phrygian, lending some support to a "Graeco-Aryan" or "Inner PIE" proto-dialect. However, the augment down to the time of Homer remained optional and was probably little more than a free sentence particle, meaning "previously" in the proto-language, which may easily have been lost by most other branches. Greek, Phrygian, and Indo-Iranian also concur in the absence of r-endings in the middle voice, in Greek apparently already lost in Proto-Greek.The first person middle verbal desinences -mai, -mān replace -ai, -a. The third singular phérei is an innovation by analogy, replacing the expected Doric *phéreti, Ionic *phéresi.
The future tense is created, including a future passive as well as an aorist passive.
The suffix -ka- is attached to some perfects and aorists.
Infinitives in -ehen, -enai and -men are created.
Numerals
- "one": *héns, *hmía ; Att./Ion. εἷς, μία, heîs
- "two": *dúwō
- "three": *tréyes
- "four": nominative *kʷétwores, genitive *kʷeturṓn
- "five": *pénkʷe
- "six": *hwéks
- "seven": *heptə́
- "eight": *oktṓ
- "nine": *ennéwə
- "ten": *dékə
- "hundred": *hekətón
- "thousand": *kʰéhliyoi
Citations